An Open Letter to Women

20130309-203749.jpg

Dear women,
I didn’t think it would come to this. At some point, I figured we would come to our senses and this would just disappear, but it seems to be increasing instead of decreasing.

I completely understand the need to join a side. In fact, I was one of you for a long time. I know it feels good to be supported and surrounded by like minded people, but this is getting ridiculous.

34.5 thousand people have shared this on Facebook:

20130220-195054.jpg

Let’s take a moment to look at this. It’s a young boy apparently empowering women who are not “skinny”. What else does this message say? It also implies that “skinny” girls are not beautiful.

You know who has been called skinny? My daughter. You know who is absolutely beautiful inside and out? My daughter.

Who do you think this picture is targeted at? I would guess it’s marketed towards young girls and teenagers. A group that is incredibly susceptible to marketing.

What the hell are we doing? Why are we hurting each other with this bullshit messaging?

20130220-195805.jpg

As a “thick” girl myself, I’m so appalled by this, I could vomit. Do I really have to get into the issues with this?

Oh, and while I’m ranting, this one is my personal favourite:

20130220-200235.jpg

Do we? Do real women have curves? Wow! I had no idea that only women with curves are real. I guess the rest of the female population is fake.

Don’t even get me started on the “Real Women Have Vaginas” images that started going around to counter these images. I’ve met a lot of people in the GLBT community that are more “real” woman than I am.

We are better than this. We have to be better than this.

Please stop sharing messaging about one size of women being better than another. Please stop dividing our gender. Please stop allowing this messaging to be made and tolerated

I’m asking you, as women to put a stop to this. We are the ones who need to take a stand. Especially before our young daughters, sisters, granddaughters, nieces, cousins and friends start becoming subjected to it.

Yours truly,
Jen Banks

  • April Wiens

    So stinkin’ true Jen .. so stinkin’ true. At this point in my life, I’m “Fat April”, but what happens if I lose 100 pounds? Will I be “Skinny April”? Why the heck can’t I just be April? Makes me CRAZY. Thanks for writing this. :)

  • Tara

    Why can’t I just be me? Why do I have to be fatter than or skinnier than? I don’t really care what I look like. I am me and it is good.

  • mclea

    “Let’s take a moment to look at this. It’s a young boy apparently empowering women who are not ‘skinny’. What else does this message say? It also implies that ‘skinny’ girls are not beautiful.”

    If you think “beautiful doesn’t require skinny” means “skinny girls are not beautiful” than I’d highly recommend you audit a grade 10 English class or look up the definition of ‘require’, lest people get the sense that you haven’t quite mastered the English language.

    • leah

      And I would ask you to take a 100 level rhetoric course, re-read the post and actually get the point.

    • http://twitter.com/LauraTFrey Laura Frey

      I read this differently, too, though I don’t see the need to be a smug asshole about it.

      Anyway. I read this as beauty doesn’t automatically mean skinny. I.e. Skinny people can be beautiful, fat people can be beautiful, or more succinctly, everybody can be beautiful. I would rather see that sign say “beauty has no shape” or something along those lines.

      I would also challenge the notion that it’s only women liking and perpetuating the other statements, which, yes, are horrible. But, I’ve heard men say those things too. I don’t think this is a women against women thing at all. Those “real women” statements are a backlash against male-imposed standards in the first place (not that it makes them okay!)

  • Tanis Miller

    My daughter is 90 pounds soaking wet, with clothes on. The ONLY curve she has is the curve of her smile. I’m okay with this. Because she is the most beautiful person I know. Inside and out. I didn’t have curves for years and I was stick thin, and it took me until I was 37 years old to feel beautiful. And it turns out feeling beautiful actually has very little to do with how I look.

  • Bree

    Thanks for this Jen. As someone who can’t gain a pound to save their life and going through tests to find out why for the last year while contending with the fight on “skinny vs fat” hasn’t been doing too much for my state of mind. Tons of support for bigger women lately has made me being stickly skinny feel less and less like a woman.

  • Jodi aka KarmicEvolution

    Women come in as many different shapes as there are women in the world. Big women are notoriously targeted for verbal abuse, thin women I find that the abuse is much more subliminal. What it all boils down to though is that people just need to stop fucking worrying about the size of their ass and worry more about the size of their hearts and minds. Women are the worst offenders for hate on women. We need to cut that shit out.

    You’re beautiful, I’m beautiful, skinny girl you’re beautiful, fat girl you’re beautiful… People are beautiful.